F. MILL OPPORTUNITIES, PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS

F.1 MILL OPPORTUNITIES

Don McCabe, Irving Pulp & Paper, Saint John, New Brunswick

- Currently commissioning a Moving Bed Bioreactor for treatment of Do and Eop

stage effluents for BOD reduction.

- Completed a digester additive trial with ambiguous results.

- Continuing with ISO 14000.

- Groundwork finished for DCS upgrade in digester area and new digester.

- New projects include a lime kiln dryer and a new green liquor clarifier with the conversion of the existing clarifier to a white liquor storage tank.

Jim Collins, Marathon Pulp Inc., Marathon, Ontario

- Will be rid of all PCB equipment by end of year.

- Kappa Factor Control in 2001.

- Buying BTG Kappa Analyser – hopefully operating by spring.

- Various projects for expansion to 580 MT/D.

- Including new 9th Digester (batch).

- Pulp Machine upgrade.

- Rebuilding # 1 turbine.

- Installed controls for brown decker conductivity.

- Start to mix CTO into Bunker "C" – cost.

- Fast tracking work on ISO 14000.

Eric Yee, Weyerhaeuser, Prince Albert, Saskatchewan

- Get approval to replace SS tower to titanium and new peroxide system.

- To replace NaOH piping in Bleach Plant – material of construction.

- Kappa Factor Control.

Ralph MacDonald, Alpac

- Operating at record production rates.

- Plan to run digester down flow low solids.

- Trialing larger chip size feed to digester.

- Lazy steam shower on press selection pulp machine.

John Brazil, Canfor, British Columbia

- Late delivery on our new paper machine headbox so fall shutdown was deferred

to the spring.

- Running the digesters 18 months between cleaning, but should be OK.

- We are still on our program of speeding up our paper machine with the goal to

be running 500 paper and 350 pulp within a couple of years.

- We are evaluating polysulphide system.

 

 

F.1 MILL OPPORTUNITIES (Cont’d)

Tina Larson, Weyerhaeuser, Grande Prairie, Alberta

- Beginning our 2 year Grande Prairie Optimisation Project (GPOP). Will increase

production by 10% and install 02 delig. (2 vessel) to address our new colour limits

for 2002 and lower yet in 2007.

- Will begin AQ pulping in mid November.

- Will be installing a Kappa Analyser and some kind of compensated kappa factor

control in June this year.

- Feasibility approval to investigate a co-generating plant on site.

Marco Solinas, Domtar

- New batch digester and blow tank at Cornwall. Lowered cooking temperature by

10oF, yield increased by 0.7% on wood (95% confidence).

- Increased consistency in D1 stage from 7 – 8% to 10%, observed substantial

decrease in Cl02 usage (1 – 2 Kg/ton).

- PS/AQ at Espanola, evaluating it for other mills.

Gavin Baxter, Tembec – Skookumchuck, British Columbia

- Record production (October 99 – September 00) at 255,000 ADE.

- New wood waste boiler starting up November, 2000.

- Pulp machine upgrades during shutdown have seen increases in daily production.

- Engineering starting on replacing our NCG incinerator quencher with a caustic

quencher.

- Operated pulp mill all summer without NG PB.

- Have approval to do some form of BP control.

Stuart Scott, Repap-Miramichi, New Brunswick

- Starting up new Ahlstrom pressure screening system on brown stock side on

Christmas shutdown.

- Ran an increased H202 trial on E1 stage.

- Engineering study being done now for pressurised 02 stage.

- Repap has been sold to U.P.M. Kymene of Finland.

- New record production of 722 ADMT/Day.

Peter Lau, Weyerhaeuser, Kamloops, British Columbia

- ISO 14001 audit – look for registration in November, 2000.

- Bob Ryan retired. Brian Dennis acting as interim Mill Manager.

- Taking market downtime – Sawdust line October 27 to December 4, and chips

line November 10 – 27.

 

 

 

 

F.1 Mill Opportunities (Cont’d)

Cam Bleackley, FCCL, Mackenzie, British Columbia

- Completed a successful 14 day annual shutdown September 7 – 20.

- In process of installing new 02 reactor for 00 stage.

- Have been operating the mill on only 1 basin since June due to requirement

by MOE/Env. Canada to dredge # 2 basin due to high furan content of the

sludge.

Ralph Lunn, Celgar Pulp, British Columbia

- Kvaerner Chemetics liquor analyser on line.

- Foxboro advanced digester control package (almost) on line.

- 20% production increase on hold pending final sale to APP.

- Screen Room de-bottlenecking underway; new knotter installed, also Quaternary

planned. Using Wingams to evaluate.

- KF control not successful due to low frequency of samples (manual tests done

hourly).

Guy Normandeau, DMI

- Down flow lo-solids trials.

- New on-line dirt scanner.

- Lazy steam shower.

- New steam hood (profiling).

- SAQ for softwood.

- Diamond roll screens.

- Kappa Factor Control for Do stage.

Gerry Pageau, HSSP

- Planning to use sesquisulphate for Do stage acidification – any suggestions for

what to do / not to do? FRP VS. Kynar, flashing.

- New corrudek drum on our Eo washer.

- Putting new top felt on 3rd press pulp machine for extra 50 ADT/day.

- Installing flowmeter and valves on digester F11 nozzles (12).

- Mill bottleneck moves to Evaporators.

- New H202 controls on Eop – feedforward from Do exit brightness.

Jim K. Oei, Western Pulp

- Chip thickness screening starting up in December.

- Phase 1 of our batch digester automation (capping valves and new DCS).

- Replacing D2 diffuser screen.

- Using C02 instead of H2 to unload S02 car.

 

 

 

 

F.1 Mill Opportunities (Cont’d)

Jim Menard, Canfor, Northwood Mill, British Columbia

- Bought by Canfor almost 1 year ago.

- Installed barrier screen with increased capacity on "B" mill.

- Installed a Valmet continuous sheet scanner on the # 2 machine.

- "B" digester is committed to "lo-solids" cooking.

- Good success from a Cl02 stack analyser following a bleach vent scrubber –

using it for feedback control. Will install 3 more monitors – Paragon.

- Filtrate extractors for pH measurement on all bleaching stages in both bleach

plants – both Kajaani and BTG.

- Permanent MgS04 system for mini 02 and Eop.

- Currently working on ISO 14001 certification.

- Currently installing a 2nd BTG kappa analyser and a FTIR liquor analyser.

- Approved a dilute H2S04 acid system to replace S02.

Jeff Dyck, Skeena, British Columbia

- Started up 2 new SVP-lite generators in late August – very pleased with the

results – we are now 100% ECF.

- We are now running a mini 02 delig. system in our B-mill, and although we are

not at full "designed" conditions, we have seen a $ 10 - $ 12./ADMT savings in

chemicals. A-mill in the next few months.

- New DCS system in B-mill – excellent opportunities to implement better

control strategies.

- Starting to pursue ISO 14000.

Murray Walters, P & T Harmac, British Columbia

- Batch digester debottlenecking.

- Recovery Boiler DCS and economiser replacement.

- Pulp machine Fourdrinier upgrade.

- Conversion of flakt dryer to Daken large steam coils.

- Kamyr digester advanced control software (Foxboro).

- Getting ready for more SPF chips.

Eric Tremblay – Neles Automation

- For one of my customers – Alcel, Atholville. They implemented compensated

kappa factor control in May. Works fine in 6 months.

Ross Stacey, Marsulex Inc.

- Extended the life expectancy of the site’s acid storage once the tank met its

minimum thickness by using a low temperature coating material at 10% of

the cost of replacing the tank.

 

 

 

F.1 Mill Opportunities (Cont’d)

Lance Anderson – Canfor Intercon, British Columbia

- Annual shutdown completed. No surprises! Annual production increased to

839 tons per day.

- Increasing pump size to brown screens for higher tonnage. Analyser installed

on Cl02 generator solution, but not on line as of today. Waiting for fibre optical

wire. Installed diagonal screens to digester upper extraction screens and will

complete next year.

- Phase 1 of Machine Room DCS complete (wet end).

Jeff Bennett, Canfor, Prince George Pulp & Paper

- Investigating ozone bleaching at D1 stage.

- Reducing bleaching costs is on-going concern.

- Modifying bleach plant and 6M screens for increased bleached paper production

and reduced market pulp production (spring 2001).

- New chip handling facility running as of March, 2000.

- Digester antiscalant trial for December-March on upper heaters.

- Planning pressure screens for 2001 on brown screens (not approved yet).

Jean Bouchard, Paprican

- Membership fees reduced by 27%.

- Research has been divided into 20 elements. Each element covering all the

aspects o/a topic.

- Membership fee splitting – 50% basic program, 35% allocated by the members

to element they judge as priority, and 15% member specific research and

troubleshooting.

Dan Davies, Degussa-Hϋls

- DH responded to 2 H202 spill emergencies in Alberta. Our Gibbons plant send

4 trucks to assist with off-loading a rail tanker that had derailed, along with

several other chemical cars. It was not a DH car, but we were contacted as we

were the closest H202 producer.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

F.2 MILL PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS

 

Jim Collins, Fort James, Marathon

Q. Has anyone tried using EKA operating conditions (chemical conc.) in Sterling

generator? We continue to have tube plugging problems. Looking to extend

life between tube cleanings.

A. Dennis Owen – Yes, saltcake filter. EKA more efficiency but washing less efficient.

R-8 responses quicker to operating changes than EKA.

Need to look at operating temperature (2oF difference from EKA (161oF) 7.ONA

and Sterling 163oF 8.1N acid.

Need to look at desuperheater temperature.

Need to change all conditions not just chemical strengths.

As you push EKA generator they can plug up.

Several EKA generators have gone to Sterling conditions.

Q. How many mills add caustic for effluent neutralisation? And how much caustic

on a regular basis?

A. Howe Sound, Alpac, PG Pulp 2.5 lbs./ton, Irving 7 lbs./ton, and Powell River.

Don McCabe, Irving Pulp & Paper

Q. Has anyone measured the Cl02 concentration in the vapour space of a D stage

upflow/downflow tower?

A. 500 ppm Gerry Pageau, 500 ppm Murray Walters.

Q. How many mills measuring their D stage tube residuals? Type of extractor,

automated(?), and if yes are they reliable?

A. Various mill responded. For manual samplers an extraction screen is employed and are usually quite reliable. For automated a filtrate piston is usually used and can be very reliable to rather unreliable.

Eric Yee, Weyerhaeuser, Prince Albert, Saskatchewan

Q Material of construction for NaOH piping in bleach plant, mild steel, stainless

steel, or else.

A. Canfor – mild steel, using Dubyis cleaning method.

Miramichi – Kynar lined steel pipe.

Chris Kanters suggests to create hardness of water.

John Brazil, Canfor Prince George Pulp & Paper

Q. Need to lower pH to the D1 stage. What is the safest way to run acid to this

stage?

A. 10% acid mixed with Cl02 before mixers. Sodium sesquisulphate to MC pulp feed pump.

 

 

F.2 Mill Problems and Solutions (Cont’d)

Tina Larson, Weyerhaeuser, Grande Prairie Alberta

Q. Seal Chests – square tile lined tanks are now found in need to be replaced. What kind of material would you use? Concern about face wire shrinking in HW

temperature.

A. Stuart Scott – FRP and D stages relined every 8 – 10 years.

Gerry Pageau – FRP – no relining.

HW not a problem because there is no Cl02 around when you shrink face wires.

Q. Weld rod on D1 254 SMO drum?

A. No answer – call Steve Clark from Paprican.

Marco Solinas, Domtar

Q. At Cornwall we run on Ep stage at low consistency (about 7 – 8%). Can we

expect significant benefits if we increase consistency to 10 – 11%?

A. Steam savings might be greater than chemical savings.

Should have chemicals. Need a mixer, if not it might get worse.

Some information in the literature.

Q. Any way of predicting outbreaks of pitch before it accumulates heavily in

storage tanks?

A. Centrifuge test (Bob Duncan).

Supplier of pitch dispersant does periodic tests.

Dirt counter for pulp (image analysis).

Cam Bleackley, FCCL, Mackenzie, British Columbia

Q. Looking for a reliable Cl02 gas analyser for B.P. stack.

A. Northwood – Paragon electrochemical unit has been very successful

($ 20,000. US).

Howe Sound – Amotech very good but very expensive.

Sterling Chemicals – Optek.

Chris Ho, Praxair

Q. Some mills looking for a reliable, low maintenance on-line pH sensor. pH sensor

tends to drift and requires frequent calibration that has caused a lot of problems

to the mill operation.

A. Recommend by Celgar and Crestbrook TB1 sensor seems to be quite good.

BTG suggests to use extractor for the pH sensor.

 

 

 

 

 

F.2 Mill Problems and Solutions (Cont’d)

Peter Lau, Weyerhaeuser, Kamloops, British Columbia

Q. Anybody use Alhmix in low C’s mixing of Cl02? Would like to get the name of

mill and its experience and contact name.

A. Nobody other than P.A.

Suggest to say with static mixer. See no advantage in mixing.

See no advantage in mixing.

Q. Kappa Factor Control with or without compensated brightness?

A. Suggest to pose question in PAPTAC Bleaching Committee bulletin board to

cover more people and more responses.

 

Ralph Lunn, Celgar Pulp, British Columbia

Q. Any experience with "peripheral" lockouts.

A. Yes, Tembec-Skookumchuck, Boise Cascade, digesters at Skeena,

Prince George.

Q. Cl02 Floating roofs?

A. Harmac – removing to allow repair of FRP.

Hinton – had to cut out to allow tank repairs.

Crofton – still in.

Weyerhaeuser, GP – still in (10 years), some stretching.

Northwood – removed after getting holes

Q. Anyone using liquid S02? (for antichlor).

A. Yes – several. Murray Walters did an E-mail survey – he will resend this out.

Guy Normandeau – DMI

Q. Combined condensate is still available at DMI. Is anyone using combined

condensate in the Bleach Plant. Where?

A. Common practice is to use combined condensate for post 02 washing.

Some applications in Europe. Counter-current washing.

Q. Antichlor Question – sodium bi-sulphite.

A. See E-mail summary.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

F.2 Mill Problems and Solutions (Cont’d)

Gerry Pageau

Q. MgOH deposits in D1 stage tower dilution plugs 6" line. It seems to be caused by

NaOH addition.

A. Reduce MgS04.

Reduce NaOH addition – go to DD instead of DnD.

Try additive.

Try magnetic device for scale prevention.

Q. HSPP is planning to use sesquisulphate for Do pH control to reduce the amount

of H2S04 used. Any comments or suggestions?

A. Keep an eye out for scaling caused by the extra sulphur in sesquisulphate.

Use Kynar pipe.

Have good acid back up system

Call Hinton or other mills which currently use it.

Jim K. Oei, Western Pulp

Q. At present we have little or no fine chips in our Kamyr feed. With the start up

of the new chip thickness screening, we will be blending pins with the chips.

Looking for input for other mills how much pins we can add and not get

digester hang ups?

A.

 

Peter Lau, Weyerhaeuser, Kamloops, British Columbia

Q. OX on pulp?

Which mills are measuring it.

Adjust process for special customer?

A. Harmac – no special run.

Squamish – Yes – lowering Kappa factor.

Howe Sound – experimenting.

Peter Gleadow, Agra-Simons

Q. Three mills in Florida have a conductivity limit on effluent discharge. Do any

mills here have a limit? Do people track internal sources (% age from

bleaching, liquor, machine)?

A. Grande Prairie (Weyerhaeuser) has a guideline.

Harmac have a guideline and a red light when they are over.

Harmac, Crestbrook and Irving have current and/or historical data on vacuum

and amounts.

Harmac data predates secondary treatment, and they could use it to estimate

volume of material (i.e., dregs or green liquor).

F.2 Mill Problems and Solutions (Cont’d)

Jim Menard, Canfor Northwood Mill, British Columbia

Q. On an R-8 saltcake slurry tank, how are mills controlling the dilution water to

the tank?

A. Skeena, Marathon, Alpac (1.18 sg.), Powell River (1.25 sg.) all Nuclear.

P.A. – micromotion density.

Howe Sound – flowmeter one continuous flow setting.

Q. Are there any mills that have gone from a bag tale system to a bulk talc system?

If so how did you justify this?

A. No mills have done this!

Ted Tunstall, Pacific, Powell River, British Columbia

Q. What pH should we be targeting for in a low consistency Do stage?

A. pH 2.5 – 3.0, 4.5% Cy, 2 – 2.5% Cl02 application.

Stan Heimburger, Heimburger and Company

Q. As bleach plant controls have been implemented, have any mills found a limit

in total H202 that can be applied based on final pulp strength losses (e.g.,

viscosity, 2-span tensile) and not on costs?

A. John Brazil (PG Pulp) – 2.5% on pulp in D(Eop) for 80% ISO pulp.

Peter Gleadow – About 5.8% on pulp now at L-P Samoa (was 9.0%).

Marco Solinas, Cornwall – use up to 5 Kg/ADT in EIP. Quevillon 2 cp less over

5 Kg/ADT H202.

Prince Rupert Pulp – 6 Kg/BDT – Eop < 2 Kg/BDT in E2P or losses seen.

HSPP - < 2 Kg/tonne (no MgS04), 2 – 8 Kg/tonne (MgS04 needed).

Weyerhaeuser, Grande Prairie – have used up to 1.5% H202 on pulp.

Canfor-Intercon use up to 7 Kg/ADT, MgS04 added in Eop and E2P.

Steve Haynes, Alpac

Q. R-8 saltcake filter system excessive wear on "wear plate". Do other mills

measure and control vacuum pressure?

A. Steam flow control valve controls to 500 mm.

Lance Anderson – Canfor.

Eric Tremblay, Neles Automation

Q. How many mills use peroxide tower in their Bleach Plant?

A. One mill – LS Quevillon Domtar mill.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

F.2 Mill Problems and Solutions (Cont’d)

Murray Walters, P & T Harmac, British Columbia

Q. Anyone notice a difference in chemical efficiency if MC Do stage temperature is

significantly increased, i.e., 110oF to 165oF?

A. Northwood went from 50C to 80C with no observed difference in efficiency.

Weyerhaeuser PA went 50 to 50C same result.

Fraser-Thurso 40C to 60C same result.

Q. Anyone using static mixers at 10 – 12% CS?

A. HSPP, Skeena, Northwood use on 02 delig. for steam mixing successfully, Also

Riavellin Brazil, Kamloops uses one in the same position but experiences

plugging and vibration.

Q. Anyone running an Ahlmix at > 1800 RPM?

A. Check with Fred Munro at Domtar Espanola.

Q Anyone have their own shower bar/nozzle designs.

A. No!

Ted Tam, Cariboo, British Columbia

Q. Who has run into environmental issues while dredging the lagoons?

A. Fletcher at Mackenzie and Weyerhaeuser at Kamloops. Also Grande Prairie

had high furan issue in the solids. All contained in landfill or basin.

Q. Who has undertaken water reduction project and how successful was it?

A. Crestbrook – water usage reduced by 2000 gpm. Now at 43 m3/l total

usage.

Miramichi – 2800 gpm reduction.

Harmac – 2800 gpm reduction.

 

Ross Stacey – Marsulex Inc.

Q. Sulphuric acid tank reached its minimum thickness at our Ft. Saskatchewan

facility.

A. Rather than replacing the tank, after evaluating several coating materials a new

low temperature cure material was used to line the tank at 10% of the

replacement cost.

 

 

 

 

 

F.2 Mill Problems and Solutions (Cont’d)

Dan Davies, Degussa-Hϋls

Q. With mills that have encountered furans in sludge, how have you handled the

sludge?

A. Weyco, Kamloops – landfill at high consistency.

Weyco, GP – landfill plan to incinerate in proposed co-generating.

Mackenzie – landfill at high consistency.

Don Olson for Gerry Ferweda

Q. What is the lowest temperature wash water / stock temperature that mills are currently processing at the back end of their brown stock washing systems?

A. Crestbrook 140F (60C)

Grande Prairie, 125F in Do, so suspect BS temp low (follow up with Tina)

Prince George P&P, 75C (167F)